logo
cuppacocoa
October 6, 2014

Three Ways to Use Rewards in a Classroom

This one is for you teachers. Someone asked me to share more about how I used class points in my classroom, so here’s a post covering all the details on the various rewards systems I had going on in my class! It’s going to sound a little complicated, but I actually had three different reward systems in place to shape student behavior: raffle tickets, team points, and class points. They each served different functions and helped keep me (and the kids) happy. They also added an element of excitement and fun to our daily life!

One important thing is that I found ways to minimize the effort and cost for me while maximizing behavioral outcomes for my students. If rewarding my students became expensive and/or troublesome, it would not be sustainable. So even if you already have systems in place, hopefully this gives you some ideas on how to make it easier for yourself throughout the year!

Raffle tickets to shape individual behavior
When to use it: building new and lasting routines, procedures, and habits in individual children.

Raffle Tickets

Here’s how it worked. I would state a behavioral goal for my students, then use raffle tickets to reinforce the desired behavior. They were usually habits and routines I was trying to establish, such as writing names on papers, turning in homework before the morning bell rang, being seated at desks and working immediately after entering the classroom without me having to remind them, etc. I would tell the students what I wanted, and then be consistent in giving out raffle tickets as soon as I saw the desired behavior.

Here’s an example. At the beginning of the year, when my students were lined up to enter the classroom first thing in the morning, I would remind them that I’d pull out about 10-15 raffle tickets and give them out to whoever started their morning work first. As soon as they got inside, students quickly took out their work and got started. As I walked around the classroom, I would quickly drop a raffle ticket on their desk. We had an understanding that they were not to grab the ticket and write their name on it right away– that would only be counterproductive in distracting them from doing their work. They would just say, “Thank you,” and continue working. After finishing their work, they could write their names and tuck it away. By the second week of school, almost all of my students would enter, sit, and start their work. I weaned them off the raffle tickets as the year progressed, but the habit remained.

They grew familiar with the process and understood that it was a little extra something from me to help them do something they were already supposed to do in the first place. At the end of each week, they eagerly anticipated the dramatic raffle drawing (even when the prizes weren’t that awesome.)

This system is great because each raffle ticket is easy and inexpensive for me, yet is a meaningful and prized token to my students. They don’t love it just for increasing their odds of winning the weekly raffle, but they appreciate the quick and easy positive reinforcement as they are building new habits.

Read more on using rewards strategically HERE.

Team points for short-term incentives
When to use it: when you have a short-term goal, like kids keeping their desks tidy during a craft, or when you need an easy motivator/prize for a class game. 

Here’s how team points work. Each table group of 4-6 students is a team. At the end of each week, the team with the most points wins and gets to be dismissed first for every recess/lunch the following week. It’s free for me, but it means a lot to them… especially when first pick at the ball basket is at stake! If I ever feel the need to remind students of how cool this prize is, all I have to do is dismiss the winning team first for the next recess, and then take my sweet time dismissing the rest of the class. When one group has already started recess, everyone else is itching to join and sitting there waiting another 30 seconds can feel like an eternity. This builds up their motivation to be the winning team the following week!

Team Points

Why team points instead of individual raffle tickets? Well, sometimes you need a little bit of peer pressure to get some kids going. I used it most often to get my students to transition quickly from a lesson at the carpet to getting started on work at their seat. All I had to do was say, “When I say go, I want you to walk to your desks and take out your books and start reading right away. First three teams get 3, 2, and 1 points! Okay, go.”

The kids swiftly stand, glide to their desks, and flip open their books in about 10 seconds. I silently take note of which teams were 1st, 2nd, and 3rd, but I wait until everyone is settled before I add the tallies on the board. If I did it in real time, then students who were lagging would have even less incentive to pick up the pace, knowing that points have already been given. The students sneak a glance at the point board, there is a smattering of “Yes’s!” or disappointed glances, but otherwise they all continue doing their work. It works like a charm, and it’s a win-win for everyone, because even the teams that “lost” are all absorbed in their work, and really, that’s a win in the real world :).

If I really really want them to do something quickly, I’ll up the ante and offer 5, 4, and 3 points to the first, second, and third place teams, respectively. Costs me nothing, but it is a big deal to them!

I offer team points in a situation like this because it’s more effective and much easier than raffle tickets. Walking around and being sure to award every individual that did things right can be a hassle, cumbersome, and you run the risk of accidentally missing someone. Sad. Also, there are some kids for whom peer pressure is more motivating than individual rewards. They might not work that hard for a raffle ticket, but they will work hard for the sake of the team. Note that I wouldn’t use team points for individual activities like starting morning work, because if someone is just unlucky and is at the end of the line entering the class, I wouldn’t want their team to be penalized for it.

Other situations when team points are handy:

It will work for pretty much anything where you’re tired of reminding them again and again. Put team points at stake, and you will see kids reminding each other of things, which means less nagging from you!

Class points to shape whole-class behavior
When to use it: When you need the whole class to do something.

Class Points

Here’s how class points worked in my classroom. If the class did something I wanted, I would reward them points. Once they reached a total of 30 points, then they earned 30 minutes of Choice Time, which would take place the following Friday. I usually did it the last 30 minutes of that Friday. For Choice Time, I would write activities on the board that students could choose from, such as playing board games, card games, math games, drawing, writing, origami, etc. Sometimes, I’d take them outside and let them essentially get 30 minutes of recess.

Students usually earned class points– walking in quietly, starting on their work immediately, everyone turning in their homework on time, students building endurance and reading quietly at their seats for 5… 10… 15… 20 minutes those first couple weeks of school. However, it was possible to lose points, which I only used in dire situations. I had a standing rule that once the 30-point goal was achieved, I would never take the choice time away. Even if they had a horrendous afternoon and got down to 0 points, I would not take away a Choice Time that they had earned. I would, however, allow their new running total to dip into the negative. (This was super helpful in teaching them positive and negative integers later on in the year!) There were times when we got all the way down to -8 points. I would always eventually make a way for them to jump back up– it’s discouraging to wade in the negatives for too long– but they got the idea.

I used class points when I wanted the whole class to do something and I wanted them all to feel the positive reinforcement immediately after. I used it when giving away individual raffle tickets was too much of a hassle, but when I still wanted to build long-term habits. These times included things like:

If you read carefully, you’ll see that there is some overlap here with how I use raffle tickets and team points. Yeah. Sometimes I just like to change it up and keep it fresh. There are slightly different dynamics and incentives and pressures when class points are at stake versus team points versus raffle tickets, so ultimately I use whichever my teacher intuition tells me will be most effective.

Here’s my little secret about class points: I oftentimes had already planned when I was going to give them their choice times. I made it work for and with my teaching schedule. For example, I wanted them to experience a successful Choice Time early on in the year so they could have a taste of what they’d be working towards the rest of the year, so I always had one planned on the first two Fridays of the year. When school first started, I made it easy for them to earn lots of points, which worked out well since I had a lot of new routines and procedures I wanted them to get down anyway. As the weeks wore on, I made it harder and harder for them to earn more points, telling them that previously rewarded behaviors were now expected. They knew this was coming, so it was no surprise to them.

A note about using class points: only challenge the class to do things you know everyone can do if they tried. Sitting at the carpet quietly. Lining up straight. Clearing their desktops. DO NOT use class points for situations where some students may not be able to meet the challenge, especially if it’s academic. Imagine how mortifying it would be if you challenged the class to all complete a multiplication handout in under five minutes, and two of the children couldn’t do it. Even if you kept their names private, they would know that they were responsible for the class not getting points, and this can be a huge burden for some children! I repeat: Only use class points for situations where you know everyone CAN meet the challenge. The last thing we want to do is embarrass or scar a kid because they tried but could not do it.

Aiite folks, that’s it. Rewards systems in my classroom. It’s a lot to keep track of, so if you’re new to it, it’s probably best to implement one at a time. If you’re just starting out, then start with something really easy, like class points. It just requires a little bit of space on your whiteboard, and let’s be honest, a 30-minute break is nice for everyone once in a while! The next easiest is team points– again, no cost to you, but provides a little competitive fun for everyone. The raffle is probably the most work– you actually have to go buy tickets, award them, store them in a container, and obtain prizes to give out. However, some very sweet stories have come from our weekly raffle tradition– perhaps I’ll have to share in a future post!

Til then, thanks for reading… hope you found it to be a rewarding read! Heh heh… :]

8 responses to “Rewards in a Classroom”

  1. Mary-Michelle says:

    I love the idea of the winning group going out to recess first for the entire next week. What a simple, yet powerful, reward! I currently use group points, but I wipe them clean each day and the reward is just another pin up for the winning group members for that day. I am going to introduce the recess reward today and try out week-long group points this week.

    I switch classes with my teaching partner two times a week, and the current behavior management system I use with my class doesn’t work as well with the short amount of time spent with the other class. I was thinking about using tickets, with a special weekly drawing, for the other class, and your post today reinforced that’s what I should do. (It was like an answer to my prayers!) Thanks for your very timely post!

    • joellen says:

      Yay I love it when timing works out well for readers. Thank you for sharing that you liked the idea(s) and I hope it all works out well for you!

  2. Florence says:

    Wooooow!!! That’s so amazing, how you must have had them wrapped around your little finger!!! ^^
    Thanks so much for that post! Either I was the one that asked about class points, or someone else asked it before I could. Anyway, as a teacher from France, those ideas are simply wonderfully genius to me!!!
    This year, I can’t use much of that because I only see each class once a week, but I can’t wait to have my own class now, and try all of that!!

    Thanks, and keep posting!! I’m pretty sure you’re doing more good than you think!

    • joellen says:

      Yep, you were the one who asked! 🙂 Thanks for inspiring this post! Thanks so much for the encouragement 🙂 It made me run over to my husband with my phone and say “AWW LOOK AT THIS COMMENT!” 😀

      • Florence says:

        My class of 10-year-olds love the class points!!
        Since I’m with them only one day a week, our goal is 15 points for 15 minutes. Just this past week I had a (councelor? Someone who comes to watch and then give you advice), so I told him about this to see what he’d think of it. He said instead of 15 minutes choice time, I should rather give them the minutes they earned at next recess, going out earlier than the others (I don’t know how recess works for you, but getting there first and claiming certain spaces for their games is real important to them!!)
        But then, they wouldn’t go through the building up of the rewarded time, and I think that’s part of the interest of giving class points.
        I’m not ready for raffle points yet, and group points can’t be rewarded your way. But keep posting! 🙂

        • joellen says:

          I’m glad the class points are working out for you! Since you only see them once a week, I agree that the same-day reward is a good call. However, I wonder if that means class points don’t matter as much after recess that day– what will they be working for at that point? Maybe it could be minutes towards some play time at the end of the day. If it’s too cold to play outside, it can be minutes that count towards the number of minutes you spend at the end of the day playing a simple game.

          OOH I should share some of those games sometime… educational, fun, flexible, time-killing games at the end of the day when you have 4-12 minutes and can’t really start a new lesson :). They’re so handy and fun for you and the students!

  3. Lena Abdullatif says:

    Do you think any of these would work for 8th graders?

    • joellen says:

      I think it could, but you need to be strategic about what the reward is. Choice time might actually be a winner with 8th graders, as they might enjoy having extra time to be social in a classroom. I’m not sure how easily you can “wean” 8th graders off rewards, though, since they’re more used to the rewards system. I imagine for them, once they sense that you’re not doing the rewards anymore, they’re more likely to revert to old habits. Not sure, and you know your kids best, but these are my guesses!